Class feedback

I love feedback! After the midterm I asked people what I could do to make the class better for them. Here are the comments (in the order they were submitted):

• Stretching breaks
• Neater writing on slides
• Be more lenient in grading
• Have a funny YouTube video every 30 minutes
• Extra extra credit (U.S.A. style)
• Make-up test
• Give people the opportunity to correct assignments, and take the average of the two grades
• Lower standards
• More interactive in class
• Solve problems in class/ review in class
• I'm doing a good job
• Missing basics (e.g. basic concepts such as revenue, operating income) creates problems
• Make equations more easily accessible: formulas, cross-reference subjects and formulas
• Pie shop example was helpful: numerical example
• Give problems and ask for creative solutions
• Homework is helpful
• Homework that consists of unfamiliar problems causes learning difficulties - better to set homework problems to reinforce things covered in class
• "Extra credit" misleading on midterm
• Change pace in class
• This class material is very well organized
• Use specific business examples e.g. example of Pets.com cost of shipping cat litter was effective
• Spreadsheets [I think the comment was that people need more practice with them]
• Income statements hard to follow
• Smaller group assignments

My initial reaction:

• I will incorporate as many of the suggestions about varied teaching methods as I can. In particular, problem-solving in class, changing the pace, more use of multimedia, small group assignments, reinforcement.
• A lot of the "missing basics" are on the wiki. If you need to revise them, look there. I will also reinforce basic concepts in class. The first half of this course introduced the concepts. The second half will be mostly about reinforcing and applying them, particularly to your group projects.
• I still feel it's helpful to give some slightly unfamiliar homework problems, to get you to think creatively about how to solve them. It also provides useful preparation for the next class.
• There is already a lot of assessment in this class. Providing make-up tests and corrections will be too time-consuming, but I will try to provide these opportunities selectively - perhaps in successive homework assignments.
• Grading is the same for everyone, so being more or less lenient has no effect on overall class standings. I accept that the designation of "extra credit" confused some people. However, everyone had the opportunity to do the "extra credit" questions, and those that did them deserved higher grades.
• I'm reluctant to provide formulas, because people tend to apply them blindly and make errors. I feel it's better for people to understand the basic principles. However, I will put a few more formulas on the wiki.
• This is an upper-level college business class. There are just things you need to learn - such as how to interpret income statements. "Lower standards" won't help you to understand business - it is what it is. 
• I promise to try to write more neatly,
• I agree with the two or three people who say I am doing a great job ;)

Some feedback for you:

• Do the homework. It's designed to give you practice on critical skills/concepts. You will get much more out of this class if you take the homework seriously.
• Don't leave assignments and exams until the last day. Start early so you can get help with problems you encounter.
• Use the class wiki. There's a lot of material there that will help you.
• Ask for help. In particular, check the class forum; someone may already have asked the question you need an answer for. Don't hesitate to post questions if you have them.

Thanks again for your great comments!